"You know what's going to happen next," declared Joe Concha, a reporter for the conservative site The Hill, declared during a Thursday morning appearance on Fox News. There are no op-eds from woke Hollywood people calling for any of this. Blazing Saddles has been streaming on HBO Max since July 28 HBO added a warning before, delivered by University of Chicago professor Jacqueline Stewart warns of … Partner with us and earn money through our affiliate program! HBO Max Adds Disclaimer to Mel Brooks’ Blazing Saddles Just as she did for Gone with the Wind, TCM's Jacqueline Stewart contextualizes the comedy classic Vivien Leigh and Hattie McDaniel in a still from the film 'Gone with the Wind'. Ultimately, this entire effort to fake a debate over "Blazing Saddles" or "Friends" or "Seinfeld" is an effort to draw public attention away from police in numerous cities who are using tear gas, rubber bullets, batons and other violent tactics to quell protests against police brutality and other forms racist violence. As for the other frequent argument, it really doesn’t matter if Blazing Saddles could never be made today. If, after the last month of American history, this is the thing you’re angry about, then there’s something … In fact, HBO Max has said the withdrawal of "Gone With the Wind" is temporary, and the service plans to bring the film back soon with an introductory video offering historical context. TCM host and University of Chicago cinema and media studies professor Jacqueline Stewart provides the intro to Blazing Saddles. The newly-launched streaming service had previously added a similar intro to Gone with the Wind, which attempts to provide historical context for some of its outdated portrayals of race. This same controversy happened back when Disney+ launched, and a few cultural scolds went nuts when they found out the company included disclaimers before some older movies, while otherwise not altering them at all. TCM host and University of Chicago cinema and media studies professor Jacqueline Stewart provides the intro to Blazing Saddles. As you’ve doubtless heard by now, in the wake of the protests that followed the death of George Floyd in Minneapolis, Warner Media announced Tuesday that it was temporarily pulling the classic 1939 film Gone With the Wind from the streaming service HBO Max. But while Kelly could go "on & on", her assumption that anyone on the left is doing any of these things is not borne out by the facts. They’re not banning it. Ted Cruz and Megyn Kelly and Joe Concha and even VDare probably understand that they're setting themselves up to be mocked by liberals for their imaginary war against imaginary censorship. Of the “Great Movies” of old Hollywood, it’s by far the worst. Instead of defending "Gone With the Wind", conservatives have bizarrely pivoted to defending "Blazing Saddles," Mel Brooks' satirical 1974 Western that depicts the trials and tribulations of a black sheriff in an all-white town. The cynicism of this is as disgusting as it is unsurprising. #FreeSpeech #ArtisticFreedom," Cruz tweeted on Wednesday. What HBO seems to not quite appreciate is that the gulf dividing Gone With The Wind and Blazing Saddles is wider than the Grand Canyon. Required fields are marked *. Unboxing the Gone With the Wind Blu-ray Boxset. The spoof comes after HBO Max included proper social context notices for Gone with the Wind and Blazing Saddles. Due to the fact that Gone with the Wind has temporarily been pulled from HBO Max due to its depiction of a rosy, slave-owning antebellum South, a new, strange rallying cry has started up on Twitter saying to ban Blazing Saddles next. If WarnerMedia/HBO were memory-holing Gone With the Wind forever, pulling it from circulation in all forms of media or, like, destroying the master negative, that would be censorship. It's already calcifying in right-wing circles that "Blazing Saddles" is somehow or other getting censored, and that's happening without a single liberal or leftist actually saying or doing anything. ", Um, OK. Your email address will not be published. Breitbart wrote a piece in 2014, listing “10 reasons to believe the left will eventually ban Blazing Saddles,” but six years later, none of the ten have yet come to fruition. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Instead of defending "Gone With the Wind", conservatives have bizarrely pivoted to defending "Blazing Saddles," Mel Brooks' satirical 1974 Western that depicts the trials and tribulations of … Sure, a mediocre parody site called Broad Street Beacon wrote a story a few years ago titled “Protests Break Out Over Proposed Blazing Saddles Showing,” but it was, you know, not real (and not particularly funny, either.) That's the true face of censorship in this country. Blazing Saddles is currently streaming on HBO Max, along with … But as always, it’s a ridiculous leap to interpret, say, “Blazing Saddles at 45: Hilarious and Troublesome” as a veiled call for censorship. Don't censor Blazing Saddles. Anything by John Hughes … Woody Allen… could go on & on… & on…& on…," tweeted Megyn Kelly, the former Fox News host whose enthusiasm for creativity does not extend to anyone who depicts Santa or Jesus as black. If not, you hate women (& LGBTQ ppl, who also don't fare well on Friends). The plot of the movie — in which the white residents of a small town chafe (at least initially) under the leadership of a black sheriff, even though he's the best man for the job — would read like a direct commentary on how Trump and his supporters reacted to Barack Obama, if the movie hadn't come out 34 years before Obama's election. Gone With the Wind has the exact same availability now that it had this time last month, and this isn’t censorship any more than well-known movies dropping off of streaming services like they do every single day. But in the meantime, Blazing Saddles remains blessedly unbanned. The Twitter account for the white supremacist site VDare (why they get to have a Twitter account is another question altogether) whined: "Black Twitter is trying to cancel Cracker Barrel. The disclaimer is similar to the one the streamer added before 'Gone With the Wind.' ", Even the kinds of right-wingers who don't pretend not to be white supremacists have chosen to flail against imaginary liberal crusades rather than defend "Gone With the Wind." If this all sounds familiar, we already did this same dance almost exactly five years ago, when then-New York Post film critic Lou Lumenick suggested that Gone With The Wind should “go the way of the Confederate flag.” Lumenick did not call for the movie to be banned or suppressed – although numerous aggregations of his piece suggested falsely that he had – and instead suggested that the film be consigned to museums. There is no call to withdraw "Friends" or "Game of Thrones" or even "Sixteen Candles," the John Hughes movie Kelly is clearly thinking about but avoids naming because she knows she can't defend either the anti-Asian racism or the celebration of date rape in the movie. If they made alterations to the film itself, I would also object strenuously, on film preservationist grounds. Is Dan Schneider a #MeToo Story, or a Pizzagate One? Blazing Saddles is the latest film to get a video disclaimer on HBO Max. (And also, not to get too judge-y here, quite a bit more comical.) The idea of "you can't make Blazing Saddles these days" has been around since the SR-71 song "Politically Correct." No one is trying to censor "Blazing Saddles," but by defending it against imaginary adversaries, Cruz can get the rumor started that there is an effort to censor "Blazing Saddles." January 1940 – The way Gone with the Wind was covered in the Black press was the opposite of how it was covered in the white press. On Tuesday, the new streaming service, HBO Max, temporarily suspended offering "Gone With the Wind", the 1939 Civil War-themed film that is simultaneously both a classic Hollywood movie and a rancid, regressive work that celebrates slavery, glorifies treason and, for good measure, romanticizes rape. She also did the intro for Gone With the Wind. Amanda Marcotte is a senior politics writer at Salon and the author of "Troll Nation: How The Right Became Trump-Worshipping Monsters Set On Rat-F*cking Liberals, America, and Truth Itself." In spite of its significance, Gone with the Wind has always been a controversial film. Also, the film’s controversy led the film’s DVD to the top of the Amazon sales chart Wednesday. The former indeed looked at … Mel Brooks' 1974 Western spoof gets a new introduction, as already happened with Gone With the Wind. Jacqueline Stewart, who recorded a similar intro for "Gone With the Wind," introduces Mel Brooks' film "Blazing Saddles" from 1974 The Curious Disappearance of Judith McNaught: What Happened to ‘The Sweetest Thing’? HBO Max adds racist-language disclaimer to Blazing Saddles. If we are to create a more just, equitable and inclusive future, we must first acknowledge and understand our history.”. The buying out of Blazing Saddles, To Kill a Mockingbird and Casablanca. "A show like 'Seinfeld', which was politically incorrect at times, that's going to be gone. The move followed an op-ed published in the Los Angeles Times earlier in the week by John Ridley, the screenwriter of 12 Years a Slave and numerous other films, suggesting that HBO “take it off your platform for now.”. HBO Max has as much right not to stream that movie as they do not to stream "Amos 'n' Andy" or "Small Wonder," the 1980s sitcom about a family with a robot for a daughter, which is not racist but just really terrible. As for the other frequent argument, it really doesn’t matter if Blazing Saddles could never be made today. And in the meantime, before Gone With the Wind returns to HBO Max, it’s right there to rent from Amazon, Apple, or other VOD providers for just $4. While it's widely believed that Gone with the Wind has very racists portrayals of slave labor, is Blazing Saddles really racist as well? It temporarily removed the film from HBO Max, a streaming service that’s existed for less than three weeks. Follow her on Twitter @AmandaMarcotte and sign up for her biweekly politics newsletter, Standing Room Only. Due to the fact that Gone with the Wind has temporarily been pulled from HBO Max due to its depiction of a rosy, slave-owning antebellum South, a new, strange rallying cry has started up on Twitter saying to ban Blazing Saddles next. CE5: Making Alien Contact through Meditation, How the Joker is the Perfect Embodiment of Carl Jung’s Jester Archetype, should “go the way of the Confederate flag.”, Vince Vaughn, Trump, and the Latest Backlash to a Non-Backlash, “Blazing Saddles at 45: Hilarious and Troublesome”, “10 reasons to believe the left will eventually ban Blazing Saddles,”, Sony is buying anime streaming service Crunchyroll for $1.17 billion, Coming Up: A one-night-only premiere of a new ‘Sopranos’ documentary, The Undoing: Demystifying the Complex Mind of a Charming Psychopath, Unpacking the Cliché-Riddled Narrative of ‘Emily in Paris’, 'Hamilton' on Disney+ is a Hit - and No, it Won't Be "Cancelled" » LIVING LIFE FEARLESS. And 'Cheers' is going to be gone, because it has mostly an all-white cast. You're next. Directed by Mel Brooks, Blazing Saddles stars Cleavon Little and Gene Wilder and serves as a satire of early Hollywood Westerns. HBO Max has been under fire since it … It's unclear how people on Twitter even could "cancel" Cracker Barrel. So, we get to do this stupid thing again, huh? Sure, the occasional thinkpiece about the movie will touch on elements that haven’t held up that well. Among the many ironies at work here is the fact that if "Blazing Saddles" were made today, the same right-wingers who pretend they are defending it from fictitious censors would be outraged at the film. But none of that is on the table, or even close to on the table. Following the Gone With the Wind news, Blazing Saddles was soon trending on Twitter. Blazing Saddles, Gone With The Wind & Other Relics Of The Past Are Going Fast! This came just two days after Shapiro had ranted about how sports media should censor all anti-racist and pro-LGBT content, and because they declined to do so, "My place of comfort has been removed from me." (There's a scene in which a group of white men, including Rhett Butler, wreak havoc on a black neighborhood, an act portrayed as necessary to defend the honor of Scarlett O'Hara. Thankfully, it was already made, in 1974, and doesn’t need to be made again. pic.twitter.com/gkLHh3JksN. (Photo by MGM Studios/Getty Images) Referring to Blazing Saddles, a … (We already covered this, but no one is censoring "Gone With the Wind" either. It’s completely theoretical, based on stuff that hasn’t ever happened and probably never will. Associated Press articles: Copyright © 2016 The Associated Press. As a response to the Black Lives Matter movement, and in an effort to wrestle with Hollywood’s racial biases, Gone with the Wind was temporarily removed from HBO Max. Is “Blazing Saddles” next? ? It’s both a dead-on parody of the racist tropes of the Western genre, and an overall condemnation of both white conservative racial panic and the tendency of right-wing plutocrats to hide behind the grievances of poor whites. The ensuing freakout was swift and immense, from those who seem to believe that, following the last three weeks of American history, THIS is the injustice worth getting exercised about. Claudine Longet and All Her Shades of Grey. Understandably, Jacqueline Stewart’s Blazing Saddles introduction is a lot less full of caveats than the one that accompanied Wind, on account of, well, Blazing Saddles being almost infinitely less racist than Gone With The Wind. She also did the intro for Gone With the Wind. They certainly don't want to back themselves into a corner where they need to explain why they're not also demanding that HBO stream "Amos 'n' Andy" or "Birth of a Nation.". I won't vouch for every joke in the film by 2020 standards, but it's not exactly subtle in picking its targets, who are the same people furious about Black Lives Matter protests today. They’re adding a disclaimer or possibly a brief pre-show discussion providing some context, both of which users will likely be able to skip via fast forward button.